Connect with us

News

Allow EC To Submit Original Documents To Mahama – JOY To Supreme Court

Published

on


Vice-presidential candidate for Seth Asiedu Walker in the 2020 presidential polls, Jacob Osei Yeboah (JOY), has noted that the current Electoral Commission headed by Madam Jean Mensah have created a courageous, transparent and competent EC.

For that very reason according to him, the Supreme Court should have given them the go ahead to to submit the original documents as requested by the petitioner John Dramani Mahama.

“It is for these reasons that I hold the opinion that SC needs to allow the EC to present documents requested by the Petitioner. My reason is accentuated on the fact of balancing the constitutional independence and unimpeded work of EC. The SC can comparatively weigh the burden of proof of responsibility and accountability from EC in election Petition with original documents provided to a Petitioner for clarity instead of the usual legal axiom that the burden of proof is from a Petitioner (he who alleges).

Secondly, it is unclear why the Petitioner would include the 2nd Respondent and President of the Republic of Ghana in the petition. There is nothing petitioned against the 2nd Respondent to warrant him being part of the case; sole responsibility of the conduct of the elections of which outcome the Petitioner is contesting, lies with the EC (1st Respondent). Although the outcome of the petition may affect the 2nd Respondent, it is still unclear why the 2nd Respondent is present to defend the actions of the 1st Respondent. Is the EC unable to defend its own actions? Clearly, the presence of the 2nd Respondent is not needed as the actions of the 2nd Respondent is not what is under scrutiny.”

Read the full statement below

PERSPECTIVES ON ELECTION PETITION AT SUPREME COURT 2020-AMICUS CURIAE; BURDEN OF EC’S ACCOUNTABILITY OR PETITIONER’S ALLEGATIONS?

Ghana has again witnessed a petition to the Supreme Court (SC) concerning the outcome of a Presidential Election. Nevertheless, there are a number of incidences that has occurred with this petition that leaves myself and a lot of citizens befuddled as to what exactly is going on. Which principle can serve Justice better and faster in elections petition; the burden of EC’s accountability or Petitioner’s allegations?

First of all, the Supreme Court on 3rd February, 2021 dismissed an application by the Petitioner, former President John Mahama, for the original documents from the 1st Respondent, the Chairperson of Electoral Commission (EC). The decision by the SC in dismissing the application for the original documents from the 1st Respondent not only serves to butter the negative perception the Petitioner has created about the EC but also prevents the EC from ably demonstrating its competence and defending its integrity. The SC can temper justice with mercy if the Bench re-examines her decision in order to help the public clear any ill perception created by the Petitioner against the 1st Respondent.

Furthermore, irrespective of whether an agent signed or not, agreed or disagreed, gave reasons or not, the actions and decisions of Presiding Officers at the Polling stations and Returning officers at the constituencies and regional collation centres are final for declaration by the 1st Respondent and Chairperson of EC. I, therefore, tend to be confused when the burden of proof is evoked on a Petitioner whose actions and documents cannot invalidate nor challenge the results of an election unless he applies for the original document from the referee according to CI-127, clause 47(5). A Petitioner, based on clause 47(5), though may or may not be having a copy of the original documents should not be denied when the Petitioner requests to understand the basis on which the Referee, Chairperson or Returning Officer made the declaration. The authenticity of the document used for declaration is with EC and can only be challenged by a Petitioner after the Petitioner has compared with whatever said copies he may be holding.

Moreover, though I’ve participated in 2012, 2016 and 2020 elections, I cannot point to an election where the EC has given duplicated documents of pink sheets to me or other candidates whose agents were not present. This is primarily due to the fact that I do not present agents at the polling stations and collation centres except the EC’s Strong room. Despite the excellent work done by the EC and my team agreeing with the declaration on 9th December, 2020, my agent left before the signing of form 13 due to security reasons, but we still do not have a copy of form 13, though all the constituencies’ results are available and the first summary sheet before filing on form 13.

For the first time, the EC under Mrs. Jean Mensa has demonstrated its motto of integrity, fairness and transparency by posting the original copies of summary documents (Form 12) of all 275 Constituencies and 16 Regions with figures on EC’s website. All Candidates agents present in the strong Room were given the regional collation form 11 (made of all constituencies figures) and regional summary form 12. Any reasonable patriotic citizen will have no doubt that posting such results of 38,622 polling stations on EC website will be messy. Naturally, using the constituencies collation form will have a few summation challenges which the Strongroom later corrected. I’ve had the privilege as 2012-2020 Independent Presidential Candidate to have personally worked and interacted with the three EC Chairpersons, Dr. Afari Gyan, Mrs.Charlotte Osei and currently Mrs. Jean Mensa. The previous two predecessors did their best in the context of the exigencies of their period but Mrs. Jean Mensa has created a niche of a courageous, transparent and competent reformer of the EC.

It is for these reasons that I hold the opinion that SC needs to allow the EC to present documents requested by the Petitioner. My reason is accentuated on the fact of balancing the constitutional independence and unimpeded work of EC. The SC can comparatively weigh the burden of proof of responsibility and accountability from EC in election Petition with original documents provision to a Petitioner for clarity instead of the usual legal axiom that the burden of proof is from a Petitioner (he who alleges).

Secondly, it is unclear why the Petitioner would include the 2nd Respondent and President of the Republic of Ghana in the petition. There is nothing petitioned against the 2nd Respondent to warrant him being part of the case; sole responsibility of the conduct of the elections of which outcome the Petitioner is contesting, lies with the EC (1st Respondent). Although the outcome of the petition may affect the 2nd Respondent, it is still unclear why the 2nd Respondent is present to defend the actions of the 1st Respondent. Is the EC unable to defend its own actions? Clearly, the presence of the 2nd Respondent is not needed as the actions of the 2nd Respondent is not what is under scrutiny.

The CI-127 aside the 1992 constitution, makes an instructive and overarching statement, clause 48(2) making the actions and decision of EC ultimately responsible and accountable for our elections except petitioned at the SC. As stated in clause 48(2): The non-attendance of the candidate or the polling agent or counting agent of the candidate at the time and place shall not invalidate the act or thing done. Therefore the 2nd Respondent has no business in this petition as he is a partaker in the election just like the Petitioner and it is the actions and decisions of the EC that is overarching and final.

I further am unable to comprehend why the 2nd Respondent would pray the court to desist from granting the Petitioner’s request for original documents which could bring clarity to the case. Why is the 2nd Respondent being allowed to play Referee and Player in the petition? This again raises the question of the relevance of the 2nd Petitioner in this whole petition as he only serves to act in ways that may frustrate the process of seeking clarity; one may direct this question to the 1st Respondent.

Thirdly, The Petitioner and the NDC have never given an inch of the benefit of a doubt to Mrs. Jean Mensa since she assumed office after she patriotically left the IEA which she co-founded. The slanderous personal allegation against the 1st Respondent and Mrs Jean Mensah makes one wonder what the Petitioner did with the previous EC Chairperson, Mrs. Charlotte Osei, which has warranted the Petitioner such seemingly prideful litigation posture and vicious hatred towards a visionary EC and Chairperson.

The dangerous political attitude by the Petitioner and NDC party is a great national security threat for citizens to distrust the 1st Respondent and EC. We have the confidence in the SC to dispense Justice that will culminate in clarity and peace to Ghanaians.

Finally, both the Petitioner and 2nd Respondent have made allegations of vote padding which favoured the other party but the 1st Respondent is yet to comment on the matter. In such a situation, the public could be served better and justice served if the election officials at those verified places are dealt with according to CI-127 45(2) instead of the Chairperson assuming the responsibility of an oath-taker. For elections officers and the agents of candidates are made to swear an oath CI-127 2(4), 19(4), 21(6) to take responsibility and accountability of their actions at their respective levels.

Conclusion and recommendation

1. The Petitioner should clearly state-specific polling stations, constituencies, regions and national collation centres they need clarity from EC through SC.

2. Unless the Petitioner states clearly any at variance action to law by the 2nd Respondent, the Court committee should clearly state his nature of engagement in Petitioner’s case against the Chairperson of EC. It is not the 2nd Respondent’s responsibility to defend EC’s actions.

3. The EC as a referee should make available to the Petitioner the original documents requested without burden of proof from the Petitioner but the burden of responsibility and accountability from EC which enjoys constitutional Independent authority to undertake her duty without impediment.

4. The Presence of agents signing and commenting is just a measure of transparency and collaborations among the candidates and the EC for wider acceptance of election results.

5. The period of elections Petition can be reduced to 21 days or drastically when EC presents original documents to Petitioners before the case management stage. The danger of discrediting revered state institutions such as the EC and SC to endanger our national security because of political sour losers will be minimised.

6. The various EC officials shall be made directly accountable and responsible for their respective actions.

7. State institutions, Candidates and Political Parties that cause mayhem and economic destruction should be made accountable according to the law especially compensation of victims of market arsons and maiming of innocent voters.

GhanaFeed.com

News

Legally, Mahama’s Petition Was Not Handled Well – Lawyer

Published

on


Private legal practitioner, Lawyer Obiri Boahen has indicated that the lawyers for the petitioner in the ongoing 2020 Presidential polls did not help matters.

According to him the lawyers failed the petitioner in presenting a valid case before the court.

He furthered that witnesses for the petitioner also failed to convince the court with their statements.

“Lawyers of Mahama failed to prosecute the case well. That is the truth everyone is failing to speak. People are afraid to tell Mahama the truth. His lawyers failed to prosecute the case well. Legally speaking, the case was not well handled,” he was quoted by rainbowradioonline.

Lawyer Obiri Boahen however, noted that the EC could be summoned by Parliament to explain the errors in the Presidential results.

Source: GhanaFeed.com

Continue Reading

News

Video: Koku Anyidoho’s Wife Narrates How Koku Sacked Her From Their Home After The Death Of Their 9-Year Old Daughter

Published

on


There seems to be a storm brewing in the home of former General Secretary of the National Democratic Congress, Koku Anyidoho as his wife has emerged to accuse him of throwing her out of their matrimonial home.

Jennifer Boahemaa Yeboah told GhanaWeb in an exclusive interview yet to be aired on the #SayItLoud programme that, following months of emotional abuse and negligence from her husband, Mr Anyidoho sent her packing from their home.

It will be recalled that Madam Jennifer was involved in a car accident in November last year which resulted in the loss of their 8-year-old daughter.

She furthered that Mr Anyidoho abandoned her after the accident, taking away their only surviving son because he blamed her for the death of their daughter.

The estranged wife recounted to GhanaWeb, how shortly after being discharged from the hospital, while arrangements were being carried out for the burial of their daughter, the former NDC General Secretary sent bottles of schnapps to her parents in the company of some friends to dissolve their marriage after their marriage of about 6 years

She noted that her family took receipt of the drinks to be used as evidence when the two families formally met to deliberate on the matter.

Madam Jennifer told GhanaWeb that what broke the camel’s back was events that occurred on Tuesday, February 23. She noted that while she was away, Mr Anyidoho packed some of her belongings from their matrimonial home and sent it to her mother’s house in a KIA truck on her blind side.

“Sending an unknown driver to bring some of my things without anyone’s knowledge, and the marriage has not been dissolved officially, I don’t know what to say… I was there yesterday trying to sort out a few things at my new apartment when I got a call from my 78-year-old mother that a KIA truck is here with some few things that Anyidoho said they should bring it…” she told GhanaWeb.

Meanwhile, Mr Koku Anyidoho is yet to respond to the allegations. When GhanaWeb reached out to him, he was unavailable.

Source: GhanaWeb

Continue Reading

News

It’s Unfortunate Mahama Dragged Us To Court Over Harmless Mistake – EC Lawyers File Closing Address

Published

on


The lawyers of the Electoral Commission (EC), first respondent in the ongoing petition hearing say it is unfortunate that they were dragged to court by the NDC’s 2020 Presidential Candidate, John Mahama.

According to them, the harmless mistake made by EC boss, Jean Mensah while declaring the election results on December 9 had no bearing on the outcome of the election which has triggered the petition.

They further stated that the former President has failed to provide any evidence whatsoever to challenge the election results and for that matter, the declaration of the result and hence, they are calling on the court to dismiss the petitioner’s case.

The submission is contained in the written closing address filed by the lawyers in compliance with the Supreme Court’s orders.

The Apex court on Monday announced it will deliver judgment on the election petition on Thursday, March 4.

Mr Mahama had filed a petition rejecting the election results as declared December 9 stating that none of the candidates who contested the December 7 polls including himself met the constitutional threshold of obtaining more than 50% of the valid votes cast.

The Electoral Commission and President Akufo-Addo were named as respondents in the petition as required by law.

The former President’s lawyers in the course of the trial served the EC with a document asking that it admits certain facts including that its chairperson announced 13.4 million as valid votes cast while handing President Akufo-Addo, 6.7 million votes.

They say the failure of the EC to admit or rebut these facts within 14 days as required by law means the facts have been admitted.

An admission of these facts they argue means President Akufo-Addo did not obtain more than 50% of the votes cast.

They are therefore urging the Supreme Court to on March 4, direct the Electoral Commission to organise a run-off between President Akufo-Addo and Mr Mahama.

Source: MyJoyonline

Continue Reading

Politics

Election 20204 mins ago

I Was The Best Man At Dr. Ayine’s Wedding – EC Lawyer, Amenuvor Shows Support At Contempt Trial

Lead Counsel for the 1st Respondent in the Election Petition hearing, Justin Amenuvor, has shown solidarity to colleague Lawyer Dominic...

Election 202051 mins ago

Election Petition Final Address: EC Admits It Made Errors In Final Declaration

The lawyers of the Electoral Commission (EC), first respondent in the ongoing petition hearing say it is unfortunate that they...

Politics6 hours ago

If The People Of SALL Had Voted, They Would Have Voted For Me – Amewu

Hohoe lawmaker, John Peter Amewu has asserted that his votes would have increased if eligible voters of Santrokofi, Akpafu, Likpe,...

Election 20207 hours ago

Mahama’s Petition Is So Weak, It Shouldn’t Have Been Heard – Akoto Ampaw’s Final Address To The Supreme Court

Lawyers for President Nana Addo Dankwa Akufo-Addo have prayed the Supreme Court to dismiss the Petitioner’s case as it discloses no reasonable...

Election 202023 hours ago

Election Petition: Another Error Discovered In Tsikata’s Closing Address To The Supreme Court

What was supposed to be a petition challenging an alleged error in the declaration made by the chairperson of the...

Election 20201 day ago

Order A Re-run Of Election 2020 Because Jean Mensa Refused To Explain ‘Changing Figures’ – Tsikata Tells Supreme Court

Lawyers for the petitioner in the on-going election petition has charged the Supreme Court to  rule in favour of John...

Election 20201 day ago

We Have Proven That No Candidate obtained More Than 50% – Tsikata’s Final Address To The Supreme Court

John Dramani Mahama says he has proven his case that no candidate obtained more than 50% of the valid votes threshold...

Politics2 days ago

Your Very Own Asiedu Nketia Gave Akufo-Addo 51.2%, JM 47% Before SC – KON to Sammy Gyamfi

Lead spokesperson for the second respondent in the ongoing petition, Kojo Oppong Nkrumah has rubbished claims by the the petitioner...

Politics2 days ago

It’s Okay For Ayine And Frank Davies To Be Friends But NDC Fights Me When I Do Same – Anyidoh Fires Again

Former Deputy General Secretary of the National Democratic Congress, Koku Anyidoho has wondered why he has been victimized in the party just...

Election 20202 days ago

‘God Is A God Of Conscience’ – How EC Lawyer, Amenuvor Responded To Tsikata’s Bible Quotation Yesterday

The Supreme Court on Monday witnessed a different presentation by counsels for the petitioner and first respondent in the ongoing...

Business

Business2 days ago

Hobort Shipping Now Delivers Items from Ghana to the U.S.A

Hobort Shipping, a global shipping service headquartered in Accra, Ghana, has taken a mega step forward, introducing a new service...

Business1 week ago

From Local To Global: Find Out About Hobort Shipping Services, The Ghanaian Shipping Company That Is Shipping Packages Affordably To Any Part Of The World

Shipping of goods and packages has become very essential especially in the modern world. With the advent of online shopping...

Business4 weeks ago

MTN Supports Africa’s Coronavirus Vaccine Effort With US$25 Million

Africa’s leading mobile network MTN has announced a donation of US$25 million to support the African Union’s COVID-19 vaccination programme. The donation will help...

Business2 months ago

Sujimoto’s Banana Island Project To Be The Next Downtown, Dubai

“You buy ‘a property’ when you want to be somebody, but you buy a LeonardoBySujimoto when you are already someone”...

Business4 months ago

SIJIBOMI OGUNDELE: How I Run Sujimoto Construction; My Story: From Agege to Ikoyi, How to Make Nigeria and Its Youths Great

Avant-garde, debonair, futuristic, and innovative is among the traits that describe the Chief Executive Officer and Managing Director of Sujimoto...

Business4 months ago

Police Withdraw Criminal Case Against Alhaji Sinare

The Ghana Police have withdrawn a criminal case against the National Vice Chairman of the opposition National Democratic Congress (NDC),...

Business5 months ago

Sub-Saharan Africa Has No Choice Than To Stick To Fossil Fuel-Dr Babajide Agunbiade.

As the world is drifting towards the use of renewable energy to power their economies, sub-Saharan Africa has no choice...

Business5 months ago

African Construction Giant, Sujimoto Clinches Time Tech Award

Sijumoto, Nigeria’s leading luxury Real Estate brand has won the just concluded Time Tech Award, a prestigious continental award organised...

Business5 months ago

4% Reduction In ‘Talk Tax’ Takes Effect Today

Mobile subscribers and data users will from Tuesday, September 15, 2020, enjoy longer durations of voice and data bundles but...

Business6 months ago

African Construction Giant, Sujimoto Explains 400% ROI In Two Years Offer

Sujimoto Construction CEO, Sijibomi Ogundele, has said that 400% return in 2 years for investing in LeonardoBySujimoto is real, describing...

Trending